DELICIOUS GERMAN ICE CREAM, CAKE AND COFFEE

The formulas of our ice cream and cake are a closely guarded secret, looking back to a more than 40 years old tradition.

LEARN MORE
VIEW MENU

Free WiFi

Hande made

Made from Milk

Fresh Fruits

Muffins

Whole Cakes

About Us

Quality meets Tradition

Peter’s Ice Cream Shop has everything you are looking for: a hometown atmosphere, passionate owners, and delicious 100% handmade ice cream. The owners, Stefan and Marika, haven't always been in the ice cream business. They both started their career as managers of major companies in Germany, but that was not their passion. Stefan continually imagined himself having his own ice cream shop in Southwest Florida. Next to all the bad things that were caused by Covid, Stefan and Marika saw their opportunity to make their dreams come true. They sold everything they had in Germany and are now starting their new lives here in downtown Fort Myers, running an ice cream shop.

Learn more

Seasonal promotions

Take a look to our seasonal promotions

Banana Split

Vanilla Ice Cream, Banana, Whipped Cream, Chocolate Sauce

$11.00
$8.00

Watermelon Lemonade

S: $2.50 | M: $2.70 | L: $3.10

Banana Split
German Ice Coffee
Strawberry Ice Cream
Ice cream

Ice cream

Hand made ice cream

Single Scoops

1 Scoop = $3.50
2 Scoops = $5.50
3 Scoops = $7.00
each additional scoop / $2.00

$3.50

Swedish Ice Cream Cup

Vanilla Ice Cream, Apple Sauce, Eggnog, Whipped Cream, Cinnamon

$9.50

Banana Split

Vanilla Ice Cream, Banana, Whipped Cream, Chocolate Sauce

$11.00
$8.00

Chocolate Ice Cream Cup

Chocolate and Vanilla Ice Cream, Whipped Cream, Chocolate Sauce, Amarettinis

$10.50

Children Ice Cream Cup

2 Scoops of Ice Cream and treats

$7.00

German Ice Coffee

1 Scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream, Coffee and Whipped Cream

$6.50

Windbeutel - Cream Puff

1 Scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream, Whipped Cream, Fruit

$8.50
Ice Cream Specialties

Ice Cream Specialties

Hand made specialties

Dog Ice Cream

Vet-approved Ice Cream for dogs. Price / scoop.

$4.00

Ice Cream Bomb

Decorated Ice Cream bowl, 34 oz. / pre-order recommended

$25.00

Ice Cream Cake

Decorated Ice Cream cake, 11” diameter / pre-order recommended

$30.00

Fuerst Pueckler Ice Cream Slice

Ice Cream made from Whipped Cream

$4.50

Our team

Who we are

  • As is generally known, that the way to the heart is through the stomach. A stay at Peter’s tends to have this effect. Please visit us and convince yourself!

    MarikaFounder

  • A long dream came true. We hope you’ll enjoy our traditional German ice cream. Don’t forget to bring your "best friend" to try also our vet-approved ice cream especially for dogs.

    StefanFounder

Location

How to find us

1617 Hendry St Fort Myers Florida

Opening hours
Mo-Th: 8 am - 5 pm
Fr: 8 am - 9 pm
Sa: 1 pm - 9 pm
Su: closed